9 Best Anastasia Brow Wiz Dupes

Are you as excited as I am?

The whole makeup industry swears by this product. ABH Brow Wiz is that one product that has replaced the traditional brow pencil for good. From its formula to its packaging, everything speaks “sleek”, like your brows!

I was a regular user of eyebrow pencils and never thought that a fancy product could change my game. I decided to get the ABH Brow Wiz 50 percent off on a sale, and I was obsessed for a while.

That was until I found some incredibly similar Anastasia Brow Wiz dupes! I have listed all 9 of them here, and each will have nearly the same effect as the Brow Wiz pencil. Are you eager to know more? Keep reading!

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz: An Overview

So what is so special about the Anastasia Brow Wiz pencil anyway, you ask?

In all honesty, this is not a super unique product any longer. It did sit on that throne for a couple of years, but now we do have some good dupes for it.

That being said, I will not negate its exceptional quality. The formula is very versatile, allowing you anything from natural looking brows to a full snatched look! Even though the product itself is thin, it is not prone to breaking with slight pressure. But do not push its limits!

It comes with a spoolie brush that is of good quality too. It brushes through each brow hair with precision. Being a retractable pencil, the packaging is important. As it has top notch quality that comes with the price tag, you will not face any issues!

If you like what you hear, you will surely enjoy the dupes! I have kept them close to the original, and they all come with a spoolie brush!

9 Best Anastasia Brow Wiz Dupes


  • Shades: 7
  • Key Benefits: Good for Sparse Brows; Hair like Strokes

This one is God sent, no kidding. I absolutely love, love, love this NYX Brow Pencil. Not only is it a stunning drugstore dupe for the Brow Wiz pencil, but I personally feel that it is better.

Let me tell you why. The pencil here is much more precise, so it helps to get thin, hair like strokes. While ABH Brow Wiz is also quite thin, this NYX Micro Brow pencil is just better.

The shade range is quite good too and the texture is very user friendly. On me, it was as long-lasting as a brow pomade. I love pairing this with a clear brow gel!

02# L’Oreal Paris Makeup Brow Stylist Definer Waterproof Eyebrow Pencil

  • Shades: 10
  • Key Benefits: Ultra-Fine; Fills in Sparse Areas

This, right off the bat, is very similar to the NYX Brow Pencil I mentioned. The pencil itself is ultra-fine, which means you can fill in your sparse brows with ease. This is especially great to draw hair like strokes for natural looking brows.

The shade range is very nice and the texture of the pencil is similar to ABH Brow Wiz. It will not be easy to overdraw with this one, so for beginners this is a great brow pencil!

The brush it comes with is also similar to Anastasia Brow Wiz, I love it! I surely recommend this.

03# COVERGIRL Easy Breezy Brow Micro-fine & Define Pencil

  • Shades: 4
  • Key Benefits: Good to add Definition; Micro-fine Tip

Just like the NYX Cosmetics brow pencil, this too is a very good dupe for Anastasia Brow Wiz. This pencil gives me such great precision, which I really appreciate as I have thick brows.

For me, this lies between the NYX pencil and the Brow Wiz. Why? Because in terms of precision it resembles NYX Cosmetics, but the texture is similar to Anastasia Brow Wiz. It is creamy but also waxy enough to have a grip.

The only downside to this is the shade range, but overall this is a great product!

04# Maybelline New York Brow Ultra Slim Defining Eyebrow Pencil

  • Shades: 8
  • Key Benefits: Fine Tip for Definition; Hair like Strokes

Maybelline is one of my favorite brands when it comes to finding a drugstore dupe.

So when I was looking for a Brow Wiz dupe, I was not surprised to find one in Maybelline. In fact, I found two! This one will give you more precision for the perfect brow. I feel that this is slightly more pigmented than ABH Brow Wiz, but nothing too significantly different.

The shade range is pretty good. I was so happy to find the right Anastasia Brow Wiz Soft Brown dupe in this product for my mom! If you need one, try 255!

Overall, there is nothing bad I could say about this product. You should try it!

Similar Article: Urban Decay Eyeliner Dupes

05# Maybelline Brow Precise Micro Eyebrow Pencil Makeup

  • Shades: 7
  • Key Benefits: Micro-Tip for Definition; Creamy Texture

This baby glides on so nicely!

For fuller brows, I really like this. I use it to add definition and then go with my tinted brow gel on top! This helps me tame my unruly brows and achieve the perfect brow!

This is the perfect eyebrow pencil to act as an Anastasia Brow Wiz dupe. It has the right kind of creamy texture. It is not like wax, but grips tightly. The texture allows it to be precise, or even as diffused as a brow powder.

I wish Maybelline came out with a dupe for the Dipbrow Pomade too!

06# Revlon ColorStay Eyebrow Pencil

  • Shades: 5
  • Key Benefits: Easily Blendable; Gives a Soft Look

If your dream brow product is like ABH Brow Wiz, but softer, then I have found you the perfect brow pencil. This is a good Anastasia Brow Wiz dupe, but the tip is more rounded. The pencil itself is a tad bit thicker to softly lay down more product.

For a few people the ABH brow pencil is not pigmented enough. Those people will surely enjoy this Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz dupe.

You have to be a little light handed and build up the brow product as you go. But you will achieve a soft look!

07# e.l.f. Ultra Precise Brow Pencil

  • Shades: 7
  • Key Benefits: Precise for Micro Brow; Has a Natural Finish

I mean, I could not finish this list without mentioning e.l.f now, could I?

This one is a great Anastasia Brow Wiz dupe for days when you need a micro brow pencil. The neutral brown shade is also an Anastasia Brow Wiz Ebony dupe!

I should mention, this is also kind of like the NYX Micro Brow pencil. But in my opinion, this is a bit stiffer to have a more brow pen like effect. So it is easier to draw hair like strokes and have a natural finish.

So if you want to snatch that micro brow look, go for this!

08# Billion Dollar Brows Universal Eyebrow Pencil

  • Shades: 1
  • Key Benefits: Creamy like a Pomade

Okay, the shade range? A disgrace.

But I will not lie, this is actually a great Anastasia Brow Wiz dupe! Why? Firstly, the creamy texture is bound to remind you of the Dipbrow pomade. Secondly, this shade is perfect for those who want an Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz Medium Brown dupe.

I love how this glides on perfectly with each stroke. This is slightly more pigmented than ABH Brow Wiz, so keep that in mind!


  • Shades: 13
  • Key Benefits: Defines; Micro-fine for Precision

I know, this is not a drugstore dupe. But I had to mention this!

This has a sharp tip for extra precision. You will definitely enjoy this if you are not a fan of rounded tips. Personally, I use this to draw brow hairs and lightly fill in the sparse areas. Then I add some highlighter on my brow bone, and that is it!

You can of course skip on the highlighter but do not skip on this! The shade range is absolutely the best!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1# Is ABH Brow Wiz Waterproof?

Ans: Yes! Even though lightweight in texture, this brow product is waterproof. For additional precaution, you can top it off with some waterproof eyebrow gel!

Q2# How Long will ABH Brow Wiz Last?

Ans: With regular use, it should last you 3 to 4 months. But if you use it on a daily basis without skipping, it should last you at least a month. Try switching between products to make it last longer.

Q3# Which Brow Wiz Color Should I Pick?

Ans: The best bet is to always match the shade of the undertone of your skin or brow hair. But make sure to pick a shade that is a bit darker than your brow hair.


So many dupes! But did you find the right Anastasia Brow Wiz dupe for yourself? You will surely find a lot of Anastasia Brow Wiz dupes, but these are the best ones! So let me know what you think!

Leave a Comment