8 Best Benefit Gimme Brow Dupes

Recently, I have been obsessed with each and every brow product I have in my collection.

If you have read my take on Glossier’s Boy Brow dupes, you must have understood my excitement.

A good brow product can really up your makeup game. If you want thick brows, a good tinted gel will turn that dream into reality. So if you are wondering I there is a good Benefit Gimme Brow dupe for that, hold your horses.

Because I have found not one, but 8 best Benefit Gimme Brow dupes that will blow your mind! So without wasting any more time, keep reading and you will find out!

Benefit Gimme Brow: An Overview

Before we delve into the dupes, I will just briefly go over the original brow product. Just to jog your memory a bit, that is it.

For nicely volumized brows, this is a great product. It gently tames your brows while tinting each hair the right amount. The product contains tiny microfibers that add to your eyebrow for giving it more volume.

Benefit Cosmetics is one of my favorites! So this brow gel and the Hoola Bronzer are staples in my routine. I love pairing this with a soft eyebrow pencil, like the Anastasia Brow Wiz.

Overall, this tinted eyebrow gel is worth the money if you have the bucks to spare!

Now, let us get to the dupes I promised you!

8 Best Benefit Gimme Brow Dupes

01# essence 3-Pack Make Me Brow Eyebrow Gel Mascara

  • Shades: 5
  • Key Benefits: Contains Tiny Microfibers; Sets Brows for Long Hours

This is one of the top dupes for Benefit’s Gimme Brow! I have mentioned this for a Glossier dupe as well- this one is just so incredibly good!

To begin with, this tinted brow gel has tiny microfibers that add volume to your eyebrows. It is a great brow mascara as the spoolie coats each brow hair nicely without going overboard. You can easily build it up for fuller brows of you like!

I cannot leave this out of my makeup bag. That means I carry it everywhere I go- great for travel to get ready on the move! Love this brow gel by Essence Cosmetics.


  • Shades: 5
  • Key Benefits: Adds Depth; Does not Make Brows Stiff

This is a great drugstore dupe because this is a very versatile eyebrow gel mascara. Firstly, the spoolie brush on this one is something that I like. As I have very thick brows, the spoolie brush in Benefit’s Gimme Brow adds too much product at times.

Apart from that, I do enjoy alternating this with my Gimme Brow. There is hardly any noticeable difference even though it does not contain fibers.

For my everyday go-to makeup look, I enjoy this thoroughly! And we all know how amazing makeup dupes NYX Cosmetics offers! I personally love pairing this with the Roller Lash mascara. But you can go for any mascara of your preference!

03# Maybelline Brow Fast Sculpt

  • Shades: 8
  • Key Benefits: Sculpts the Brows; Adds Pigment

If you have sparse hairs in your brows, you may really enjoy this spoolie brush. Why? Because it coats each brow hair with a generous layer of product without overdoing it. That is right, just like Benefit Gimme Brow!

This one comes in 8 shades. My friend bella loves the warm brown shade for a browny brow!

Also, if you want the Gimme Brow effect but without the tint, you will get that too! Just use the clear brow gel and go with the Brow Wiz or any eyebrow pencil!

Maybelline truly is a great brand in the beauty industry. The Superstay concealer is my go-to with the brow gel for a no makeup makeup day. And if you have the Benefit Roller Lash, add a layer of that to your lashes!

04# e.l.f. Wow Brow Gel

  • Shades: 5
  • Key Benefits: Contains Microfibers; Adds Volume

Okay, so I really was not going to skip on this, right? I mean, this one is a straight up drugstore dupe for so many high end brow products!

This one contains tiny microfibers, similar to Benefit Gimme Brow. So it is for sure that it will add a ton of volume and fluffy. You will find this 5 shades, all very close to Gimme brow.

I am sure I do not need to say a lot about this as you all know my love for it. But is it a good dupe for Benefit Gimme Brow? It definitely is in my books!

Plus this is like so cheap, all of you should buy one and give this a go! And for a Benefit Gimme Brow dupe Elf is one of the best.

Similar Article: Anastasia Brow Wiz Dupes

05# L’Oreal Paris Unbelieva-Brow Tinted Waterproof Brow Gel

  • Shades: 5
  • Key Benefits: Long-Lasting; Waterproof

The reason why I am mentioning this as a Benefit Gimme Brow dupe is very specific. Personally, I believe that the way it tints each brow hair is similar to Benefit Gimme Brow.

The tint is almost like a pomade, but the texture is also like it. This is what makes this eyebrow gel so long-lasting. Plus, this is waterproof like Benefit Gimme Brow, so you might enjoy that too.

Overall, I think that this makes the list as a Gimme Brow dupe, but why do you not try and see? I am sure you might agree with me wholeheartedly!

06# L’Oreal Paris Cosmetics Brow Stylist Boost and Set Brow Mascara

  • Shades: 4
  • Key Benefits: Good for Sparse Brows; Mousse-like Texture

You might wonder, why am I mention this as a Benefit Gimme Brow dupe? Well, again I have a very specific reason. The texture is very mousse-like, so it gives you a very fluffy and feathery appearance like Benefit Gimme Brow.

Other than that, it is great for people with sparse brows to achieve the perfect brow. The wand is very thin, which allows precision. That being said, this is also great for thick brows. But it just coats sparse hairs with amazing precision, without clumping?

This is also great for people with sensitive eyes. Just put this on and add some highlighter on your face and brow bones. You will be editorial ready!

07# Rimmel Brow This Way Lightweight Gel

  • Shades: 3
  • Key Benefits: Adds Definition; Lightweight Texture

Oh my God, this Rimmel eyebrow gel is such an old favorite of mine! I used this before I got my hands on the Gimme Brow. And immediately I thought, that this is a great Benefit Gimme Brow gel dupe!

This one does not contain microfibers like Gimme Brow. So do not expect a ton of volume. But, the texture is so airy and lightweight, so much like Gimme Brow! This can be a great Benefit Gimme Brow alternative if you do not mind the lack of volume.

It just adds such nice definition to the brows that I really like. The shade range is range in not very good though, so keep that in mind.

But do give this a try, Rimmel is such a classic!

08# Maybelline New York Eyestudio Brow Drama Tinted Gel Mousse

  • Shades: 5
  • Key Benefits: Sculpts the Brows; Mousse-like Texture

Last on my list is this another lovely product by Maybelline. I love all Maybelline skin products, and its brow products are bomb too! This one is a good dupe for Benefit Gimme Brow.

The brush allows to fluff up the brows like Gimme Brow. But has a nice sculpting effect that adds definition. You can skip on the highlight if you like.

As I mentioned before, the mousse-like texture is lightweight but effective. It helps to keep the brows in shape without any stiffness, the same way Gimme Brow does.

Overall I really enjoyed this and recently brought a backup. So if that does not prove that I am a fan, I do not know what will.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1# Which Benefit Brow Product is the Best?

Ans: Definitely the Gimme Brow Gel tops the list! If you can pair it with the Precisely My Brow pencil, you will love the finish look! Both are one of the best brow products by Benefit Cosmetics!

Q2# Is Brow Gel or Brow Pencil Better?

Ans: It definitely depends on your needs. If you need to set and shape your brows, and to add volume, you need a brow gel. But to fill in sparse areas and to draw on hair like strokes, you need a brow pencil!

Q3# How Can I Choose the Right Gimme Brow Shade?

Ans: Pick a shade that is slightly darker than your brow hair. Also one that matches the undertone of your skin. That will allow a seamless match and the right kind of definition that you will like.


I have not been able to skip on brow products lately. Once I figured the products that I enjoy, I have been obsessed! But some products are a little too expensive.

So I hope the 8 best Benefit Gimme Brow dupes help you! Each product is a good dupe for Benefit Gimme Brow for certain reasons. Pick a one that feeds your needs and let us know which one you like!

Leave a Comment